13.2 C
London
Sunday, October 2, 2022

‘The world is my oyster’: Nicola Sturgeon on feminism, her final push for independence and life after politics | Nicola Sturgeon

Nicola Sturgeon received’t take “no” for a solution. Standing at one finish of the lengthy desk within the cupboard room at her official Edinburgh residence, Bute Home, her white go well with jacket is mirrored within the shiny mahogany. Sturgeon is satisfied that the ultimate scene of Soiled Dancing features a second when Patrick Swayze leaps on to a desk similar to this. Two younger girls on her political workers disagree: Swayze was dancing down the aisle, they insist – appropriately. How can she not bear in mind this; what number of instances has she watched it? It’s the primary rule of Scottish interplay that the extra you want an individual, the extra you are taking the piss out of them. Maybe it’s the sunny afternoon or the marginally much less punishing schedule of Holyrood in recess however, for now at the very least, Scotland’s longest-serving first minister is in a playful temper.

We’re assembly two weeks after Sturgeon named the date for a second Scottish independence referendum as 19 October 2023, and revealed her plans to take the combat to the UK’s supreme court docket by asking judges to rule on the legality of holding the vote with out Westminster’s permission. Earlier within the day, she held a press convention within the elegant first-floor drawing room, to launch the second in a collection of Scottish authorities papers making the case for independence. Poised on the podium beneath a portrait of Robert Burns, she was on ebullient kind as she condemned the Tory management contest’s “wholly manufactured tradition battle” and accused Keir Starmer of giving “the proverbial two fingers to Scotland”, an uncharacteristically coarse jibe for the often lawyerly Sturgeon.

She appears noticeably upbeat, I inform her as we sit throughout from one another on the cupboard desk. Does it really feel as if the momentum is constructing now? “I’ve set out a transparent path ahead, so I’m feeling up for that,” she says, as she fiddles with the “first minister” place marker in entrance of her. Sturgeon loves a fidget – her clicky pen is infamous throughout briefings.

The primary minister, who’s 52, means she’s “up for” one other marketing campaign for independence – however she additionally has one eye on her personal post-Holyrood future. Whereas insisting that she has “actually not dominated out standing once more”, she can also be clear that “at any time when I do cease being first minister, I’m nonetheless going to be comparatively younger. This may not at all times have been true of me, however a life after politics doesn’t faze me.”

She is trying ahead to some privateness – “simply not feeling as when you’re on public show on a regular basis” – however can’t think about a world position that takes her too removed from Scotland “as a result of I’m a homely particular person”. With all the same old caveats and sub-clauses one expects from a political chief in interview mode, she concludes, “The world is my oyster,” which can at first appear jarring from the girl who has simply positioned the UK on purple alert for a second referendum.

Portrait of Nicola Sturgeon on stairs at Bute House
‘I take very severely the truth that I’m first minister for all Scotland.’ {Photograph}: Manuel Vazquez/The Guardian

And it raises the query: is that this the ultimate lap for one of the vital common, trusted and succesful politicians of her period, a girl who adopted Woman Gaga in filling the 12,000-seat Hydro area in Glasgow when she first took workplace in November 2014 and, eight years on, nonetheless enjoys wholesome approval ratings? And will her record-breaking run of success in Holyrood and Westminster elections conclude with the top of the union?


So, how seemingly is one other referendum, given the numerous doubts that any of the three routes she proposed will truly ship. It’s a path “not with out hurdles alongside the best way”, she says with some understatement. The UK authorities has persistently refused plan A, the section 30 order that may grant Holyrood the powers to carry a authorized vote, whereas constitutional specialists are sceptical about plan B; that the supreme court docket will rule a referendum is authorized with out Westminster’s approval.

Is there time to suit all of the shifting elements, together with Holyrood laws and an anticipated 16-week marketing campaign interval, earlier than the set date of October 2023? Sturgeon is sanguine: “Assuming there’s a judgment spherical in regards to the flip of the 12 months, then we can take laws by means of on a timescale for [a vote on] 19 October.” In the meantime, her plan C if all different routes are exhausted, to combat the following basic election on the query of independence alone – a “de facto referendum” – is already mired in procedural confusion: would success imply a majority of votes only for the SNP, or would different pro-independence events rely in the direction of the tally? How can one occasion dictate the phrases of an election? And so forth.

For now, Sturgeon faces two associated challenges: tips on how to preserve momentum amongst her personal activists because the courts and parliament go into summer time hiatus; and the existential query of how she manages a marketing campaign in a rustic that’s cut up down the center. Polling over the previous 18 months reveals help for each sure and no hovering round 50% on whether or not Scotland ought to finish its 315-year-old union with the remainder of Britain.

“I spend numerous my time fascinated about that, as a result of I take very severely the truth that I’m first minister for all Scotland,” she begins, earlier than insisting that “for almost all of individuals, not all people, the purpose of unity is round democracy because the path to settle that”.

She characterises a referendum as a hopeful different to a number of home and worldwide crises, however some sure activists warn towards complacency: the belief that Brexit or the price of dwelling make independence an apparent different, when in reality voters who really feel susceptible usually tend to cling to the established order.

“There’s no ounce of complacency on my half. I’ve spent the previous few years with individuals inside the sure motion saying, ‘Why don’t you go for it now, as a result of clearly persons are going to vote sure, given the state of the UK?’ I’ve by no means thought it’s that easy.” She sounds mildly exasperated. “This isn’t simply selecting up from the lead to 2014. This can be a contemporary debate.”

With the post-Johnson Tories in handy chaos, at this time she reserves her hearth energy for Labour, whose electoral success is way extra of a risk to independence help. After years of self-defeating equivocation on the structure, Starmer and the brand new Scottish Labour chief Anas Sarwar have introduced a much more unified entrance. The council elections in Could noticed Scottish Labour re-emerging because the closest challenger to the SNP because the Scottish Conservatives plunged to their worst electoral lead to a decade.

Just like the Tories, Starmer has refused to countenance a bit 30 order if Labour takes energy, and in July he dismissed a Westminster take care of the SNP, telling the Scottish foyer: “There isn’t any alliance to be cast with a celebration that wishes to interrupt up the UK.”

Senior Labour figures are identified to be pushing Starmer to be strident on the SNP, in an effort to spike renewed Conservative assaults on a “coalition of chaos”, and Sturgeon is acute in her response: “It’s not about successful votes in Scotland; it’s about successful votes in England. I believe they’d win extra respect in England if they really stood as much as these Tory assaults, reasonably than crumble within the face of them.”


For many progressive voters outdoors Scotland, the chief of the SNP can seem to be the very best chief they by no means had. When she appeared in her first leaders’ debate for the 2015 basic election alongside David Cameron and Ed Miliband (simply six months after her predecessor Alex Salmond stood apart having misplaced the primary independence referendum), “Can I vote for the SNP if I reside in England?” grew to become one among Google’s high searches of the night time.

This admiration at one take away peaked through the Covid disaster. Whereas Johnson supplied Churchillian bombast, Sturgeon pledged to deal with the individuals of Scotland as grownups at her day by day briefings, and spoke on to anxious youngsters in her nationwide broadcasts. Her warning – imposing tighter native lockdowns than elsewhere within the UK – drew criticism from Scottish dad and mom and companies, however was praised by epidemiologists, and infrequently England adopted the place Scotland (and Wales) led, for instance on face masks in outlets and faculties.

Identical to Boris Johnson, she is referred to throughout Scotland by her first identify – “our Nicola”, or “bloody Nicola”. In an age of political hyper-management, evasion and misinformation, Sturgeon comes throughout as direct, thought-about and remarkably human.

There’s a flip facet, in fact. Her home opposition level out that grandstanding on the UK stage prices her nothing and presents a straightforward distraction from her occasion’s variable file on schooling, transport, hospital ready instances and drug deaths, and the truth that, after 15 years in authorities, many progressive pronouncements have but to be delivered. She was referred to as “Elsie McSelfie” on Twitter after posing with celebrities finally 12 months’s Cop26 local weather convention in Glasgow. Opponents depict a weary, opaque and complacent administration with just one thought left.

However nonetheless the SNP continues to dominate Scotland’s political panorama, because of Sturgeon’s success in harnessing sure voters behind her occasion after the frustration of September 2014. Final Could, the occasion received its fourth consecutive Holyrood victory.


The first minster’s manner at this time is a world away from the winter of 2020-21, when Covid instances have been surging once more, simply as Alex Salmond vented his fury for what he claimed was a “malicious plot” to destroy his repute orchestrated by senior officers near Sturgeon.

“There was a interval the place I used to be attempting to steer the nation by means of a world pandemic, and on the identical time attempting to face up to a full-frontal assault by my predecessor to convey me down,” she says, as if she nonetheless finds it arduous to compute.

Sturgeon with Alex Salmond in 2012.
With Alex Salmond in 2012. {Photograph}: Murdo MacLeod/The Guardian

Coming by means of it “has proven me that I’m a bit extra resilient than I believed”, she displays; “extra assured in my very own pores and skin”. “Having to take care of Covid additionally allowed me – even given the poisonous horribleness of the Salmond stuff – to place it into perspective in a manner that I in all probability wouldn’t have been capable of do had it been by itself with out that backdrop.”

That “poisonous horribleness” started when particulars of sexual harassment complaints made towards the previous first minister by two feminine civil servants have been leaked to the Each day File in August 2018. Salmond instantly launched a court docket problem and received a major authorized victory towards the Scottish authorities after the civil service admitted its inside investigation had been mishandled.

However then, in a growth that shocked the Holyrood institution – together with Sturgeon – Salmond was charged with a number of legal counts of sexual assault, which included the 2 unique complaints. He was acquitted of all prices on the excessive court docket in Edinburgh in 2020, however by then his sense of betrayal had a ferocity that these near Sturgeon say she was not ready for. The SNP is commonly described as extra like a household, led by a tight-knit group who’ve stored religion collectively throughout many years of public unpopularity. On the coronary heart of that household was the symbiotic relationship between Sturgeon and her mentor Salmond. As she informed the Holyrood inquiry: “He was a very shut good friend of mine that I cared about.”

After two high-profile investigations final 12 months into the Scottish authorities’s dealing with of the preliminary complaints, together with Sturgeon’s personal conduct, she was finally cleared of deceptive parliament. However what the unique two complainants referred to as a “tradition of complicity” was uncovered round Salmond’s allegedly inappropriate behaviour throughout his time as first minister. This was “very troublesome for anyone in authorities to learn”, Sturgeon mentioned quickly after.

Early on, it appeared that the Salmond saga would possibly show to be Scotland’s #MeToo second – it grew to become as an alternative a psychodrama about two titans of Scottish nationalism. As Sturgeon informed me a couple of weeks after the inquiries concluded: “For those who’re a girl in Scotland over the previous 12 months or so, what you’ve witnessed is a complete political class and an inquiry of the nationwide parliament at instances indulging and amplifying the topic of complaints, saying that it was all a conspiracy, questioning the motives of the ladies who got here ahead, successfully saying that as a result of there was an acquittal in a legal trial that was tantamount to them mendacity.”

At Bute House.
Swimsuit, by Veronica Beard; knit, by Joseph; footwear by Jimmy Choo. Necklace and pendant, by Ellis Mhairi Cameron, aetla.co.uk. Above and high photos: go well with, by Pinko; shirt, by Membership Monaco; footwear, by Jimmy Choo (all garments from Harvey Nichols, Edinburgh). Gold pendant, by Ellis Mhairi Cameron, as earlier than. Stylist: Amanda Blackwood. Hair: Zoe Harrison. Make-up: Jak Morgan.
{Photograph}: Manuel Vazquez/The Guardian

The reviews additionally revealed ranges of presidency mishandling that examined credulity and the lingering suspicion that issues weren’t pursued due to their seemingly influence on the paramount objective of independence. With that got here respectable questions and criticism of Sturgeon herself, however all through there was additionally that queasy sense {that a} girl was being held accountable for a person’s inappropriate behaviour.

But a 12 months on, the occasion continues to be going through questions on the way it handles such complaints. In June, the Guardian revealed {that a} new system for coping with sexual harassment complaints inside the SNP is predicted to lastly grow to be occasion coverage this summer time, after escalating frustration from activists about lack of accountability.

Sturgeon meets the criticism sideways. “I usually really feel pissed off in regards to the size of time issues take going by means of occasion processes, however notably with insurance policies round harassment or bullying, we have to be sure that we’re doing issues in a manner that’s legally strong as properly.”

In June, she condemned the behaviour of her personal MPs as “totally unacceptable” after it appeared that some within the Westminster group have been defending their senior colleague and former chief whip Patrick Grady, who had been suspended for making an undesirable sexual advance to a teenage workers member. And two weeks after our interview, the SNP chief of one among Scotland’s largest councils, North Lanarkshire, resigned following allegations of inappropriate behaviour.

Does the SNP have an issue with sexual harassment? Sturgeon doesn’t hesitate: “I might not say that the SNP has no points there, as a result of I believe actually each organisation, each political occasion has these points. It’s very deeply embedded in society. It’s about males’s attitudes in the direction of girls; it’s about intercourse and energy. Really attempting to take care of the basics,” she provides, “is usually tougher than simply ‘one thing occurs and any person resigns’”.


Scottish independence has been Sturgeon’s lodestar all her life. She grew up within the new city of Irvine on the North Ayrshire coast, along with her youthful sister and fogeys Robin, an electrician, and Joan, a lab technician. She stays particularly near her mom, who served as an SNP councillor for a decade. It was the devastation wreaked by Margaret Thatcher and the hopelessness she witnessed amongst her friends that spurred her to affix the SNP as a serious-minded 16-year-old. Within the Eighties, the occasion was on the margins and membership was not about forging a profession in politics. She has mentioned earlier than: “My era got here into this purely out of conviction.”

The primary in her household to attend college, she was the youngest ever parliamentary candidate in Scotland within the 1992 basic election, on the age of 21, earlier than finishing her legislation finals on the College of Glasgow. She labored as a solicitor in her 20s, then entered the newly created Scottish parliament in 1999.

Sturgeon with her husband Peter Murrell as voting began in the local government elections in May this year
With husband Peter Murrell as voting started within the native authorities elections in Could this 12 months. {Photograph}: Jane Barlow/PA

Sturgeon has married inside the occasion: her husband, Peter Murrell, is the chief govt of the SNP, a focus of energy that has raised loads of issues about transparency over time, and notably amongst MSPs through the Salmond inquiry. They wed in 2010, and Sturgeon enjoys presenting herself as undomestic in distinction to Murrell, bantering with him on social media about her hopelessness within the kitchen.

Sturgeon is an inveterate Twitter person, managing her personal account in contrast to many senior politicians, sharing swift rebuttals but in addition ebook suggestions: she is evangelical about studying, and tells me she is now having fun with Worldwide Booker winner Tomb of Sand by Geetanjali Shree. Throughout lockdown, the broadcasts from her constituency house in Glasgow revealed heaving cabinets (alphabetised, then in chronological order by creator).

Her public persona is commonly characterised as a “nippy sweetie”, a Scottish description – largely utilized by males, about girls – for a sharp-tongued particular person. Undoubtedly she shouldn’t be a glad sufferer of fools and typically finds it arduous to hide her irritation. Longtime observers recommend she shouldn’t be a pure extrovert and has labored arduous to develop a convincing and empathic public type.

However there are additionally the off-camera moments I’ve witnessed over eight years of reporting on her premiership: her capability to make fast and real connections with younger dad and mom; her behavior of acknowledging extra junior girls within the room at conferences to make them really feel included; her potential to reassure an anxious aged constituent who has waylaid her on the best way in to a group centre, listening to him as if she has on a regular basis on the planet.

Although when the allure is absent it’s arctic: she may be exceedingly short-tempered with journalists who don’t ask what she considers to be the best questions, and there have been some excruciating moments throughout Covid briefings when Sturgeon would berate reporters, accusing them of attempting to get a straightforward headline after they have been merely attempting to do their jobs.


While Sturgeon describes herself as “naturally fairly a reserved and shy particular person”, she has spoken candidly about private challenges that many ladies will relate to. In 2016, she mentioned having had a miscarriage aged 40 simply as she was making ready to share the information of her being pregnant with family and friends. She did it to confront assumptions, she explains now, “as a result of if you’re a girl, notably in a senior place with out youngsters, there may be an assumption made that you just’re a cold-hearted bitch that has determined to prioritise your profession over having youngsters”.

I’m curious to know if she has ever felt judged for not having youngsters. “I’ve been topic to numerous scrutiny and commentary about it. Is that being judged?” she asks herself. “I don’t know. And males don’t get that. The proper illustration is me and Salmond: I can’t recall a single interview that he did in his complete time as first minister or SNP chief about why he didn’t have youngsters.”

In an interview with Vogue final autumn, Sturgeon talked about that she and her husband had mentioned fostering. “We now have talked about it in very, very basic phrases,” she says now, with some warning. “That has come from the work I’ve executed with care-experienced younger individuals, which has actually received underneath my pores and skin. I’ve seen the distinction that good foster dad and mom could make.”

Earlier this 12 months, she mentioned her expertise of being “within the foothills” of the menopause on The Shift, a podcast that includes girls in midlife. She informed host Sam Baker: “I’ve received home windows open within the depth of winter; my poor husband is shivering. I’ve thought to myself: what if that occurs after I’m on my toes in parliament in the course of first minister’s questions?”

What prompted her to talk out? “These are nonetheless such huge issues for ladies, shrouded in a lot thriller and likewise plenty of stigma,” she says. “I’m the primary girl on this workplace and solely right here for a comparatively quick time frame, so if there are issues you are able to do to attempt to transfer the dial just a little bit, I’ve received some obligation to try this.”


When I started reporting on Sturgeon as first minister, she had appointed the nation’s first gender-balanced cupboard and appeared within the Holyrood chamber alongside two different feminine occasion leaders – expectations have been excessive. These days I appear to spend as a lot time reporting on different girls’s disappointments along with her.

However any feminine chief, even one as publicly feminist as Sturgeon, shouldn’t be the cure-all for systemic inequality – she should carry along with her a celebration, authorities and certainly nation that lags behind. So I ponder typically how a lot of individuals’s disappointment within the glacial tempo of change will get pinned on Sturgeon as a result of she’s there.

She has more and more grow to be the main target of opposition to SNP plans to introduce a simplified system by which transgender people can change the intercourse recorded on their beginning certificates – often known as self-identification. Final June, on the ultimate proof session of the Holyrood committee inspecting these plans, the listening to needed to be quickly suspended after plenty of girls immediately revealed T-shirts that learn: “Nicola Sturgeon: destroyer of ladies’s rights”.

How does it really feel to learn that slogan? “I bow to nobody in my dedication to feminism …” Sturgeon is so definitive on this level that her voice cracks. She doesn’t reply my query immediately – “Individuals have a proper to say these items in a democracy” – however she does go on to reply the query that no politician can escape within the present local weather: are you able to outline a girl? She was closely criticised on the native elections for refusing to take action.

She says: “The overwhelming majority of ladies are individuals like us, who have been born girls and are organic girls, and a really small quantity who’re trans girls – who’re girls. When that query is requested, often it’s an invite to exclude the tiny variety of girls who’re trans,” she says, her frustration clear as her supply accelerates, “and I’m not going to do something to additional exclude and stigmatise them.”

She repeats her earlier concern in regards to the rightward route of the Tory management contest. “There are actual threats to girls proper now, from the assault on our reproductive rights, the misogyny that’s nonetheless rife throughout our society, the threats and actuality of sexual violence that girls face each day. That’s what feminists ought to be targeted on. Trans girls are usually not the risk to girls.”


Before she leaves, I return to the query of her future. When Sturgeon talked about fostering final October, it was the primary sign that her thoughts was on life past Holyrood. “I’m not about to give up the stage,” she says evenly, and whether or not she stands on the subsequent election is a judgment she’s going to make nearer to the time. “However I stay up for the chance to do different attention-grabbing issues after politics.” It’s telling that she doesn’t resort to a politician’s reply right here, insisting that by then she will likely be negotiating the phrases of the breakup of the UK having received the second independence referendum.

And what it tells you is dependent upon the place you stand on Sturgeon. Is it proof that her coronary heart’s not likely in her plan for an additional vote, that she doesn’t imagine it is going to occur or that she will win it? Or is it a refreshingly reasonable response from a girl who’s, simply possibly, executed with worrying about how anybody else interprets her? Her – said at the very least – refusal to cling to workplace is a marked distinction to the likes of Tony Blair or Boris Johnson.

It’s time for her portraits. Sturgeon stands alone, trim-figured and tiny with out her trademark heels, dwarfed by the lighting rig. She swings her arms and bounces on her stockinged soles like a gymnast limbering up for the vault. She’s prepared for what comes subsequent.

Latest news

Related news